Kenya’s Repeated Internet Shutdowns Raise Concerns About Digital Rights
Kenyans’ access to information and communication was recently restricted again with the reported blocking of the Telegram messaging app in November 2023. This follows a similar internet disruption during protests against the Finance Bill in June 2024. These incidents raise serious concerns about Kenya’s commitment to digital freedom and its potential impact on the country’s development.
The Internet Society, a global non-profit organization advocating for an open and secure internet, has previously condemned such practices. In a 2023 statement, they highlighted how “specific app and service bans are fragmenting the internet” and restricting access to vital communication tools. This fragmentation creates a digital divide, where some Kenyans have access to a wider range of information and communication channels than others. This can exacerbate existing inequalities and hinder inclusive development.
Furthermore, internet shutdowns can have a chilling effect on freedom of expression. When people fear that their online communications will be monitored or blocked, they are less likely to speak out on sensitive issues or engage in critical discourse. This can stifle democratic participation and hinder the flow of information that is essential for a healthy society.
Curtailing Rights and Information Flow
Civil society organizations in Kenya, like KICTANet (Kenya ICT Action Network), have also spoken out against these shutdowns. They emphasize that such actions violate fundamental human rights enshrined in the Kenyan Constitution and international law, including freedom of expression and access to information.
By blocking access to platforms like Telegram, the Kenyan government hinders communication and information sharing in several critical ways. First, it disrupts the ability of people to organize and participate in peaceful assemblies. Social media platforms and messaging apps have become essential tools for mobilizing people and raising awareness about important issues. Blocking these platforms can effectively silence dissent and hinder democratic participation.
Second, internet shutdowns can restrict access to vital resources and information. Many Kenyans rely on online platforms to access healthcare information, educational resources, and news updates. Blocking access to these platforms can have a significant impact on people’s well-being and ability to make informed decisions.
Third, internet shutdowns can disproportionately impact marginalized communities and human rights defenders. These groups often rely on online platforms to communicate securely and share information about human rights abuses. Blocking these platforms can silence their voices and hinder their ability to hold the government accountable.
Economic Disruption and Loss of Trust
Internet disruptions also have a significant economic impact. According to a 2023 study by the World Bank, a one-day internet shutdown in a developing country can cost the economy millions of dollars. This is because businesses rely heavily on the internet for online transactions, communication with customers and suppliers, and marketing activities. Disruptions can also lead to lost productivity and hinder access to essential online services, such as e-commerce platforms and mobile banking.
The negative economic impacts are not limited to the immediate duration of the shutdown. Repeated internet disruptions can create a climate of uncertainty for businesses and investors. This discourages investment in the digital economy and can stifle innovation. Businesses may be hesitant to invest in online infrastructure or develop new digital products and services if they fear that the government will arbitrarily shut down the internet.
Furthermore, repeated internet shutdowns erode public trust in the government’s commitment to digital governance. When citizens perceive that the government is willing to restrict internet access to silence dissent or control information flow, it undermines trust in the government’s ability to manage the digital economy effectively. This can lead to decreased cooperation with government initiatives and hinder efforts to promote digital inclusion.
Alternative Solutions are Needed
Kenya should explore alternative solutions to address concerns about online activities. Collaboration with tech companies, education campaigns to address misinformation, and strengthening law enforcement capabilities are all viable options.
Upholding internet freedom is not just about access; it’s about fostering trust, innovation, and economic growth. Kenya must find a way to address its concerns without resorting to disruptive and rights-violating shutdowns.
About Author
